Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Jeremy Myerson discusses Disney’s The Hunchback of Notre Dame!

February 17th, 2010

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Jeremy Myerson, in which he discusses his favorite Disney movie.

Everyone remembers the villain in the Scream films asking, “What’s your favorite scary movie?” just before he claims a victim. Easy enough question, as everyone can answer it. As a former employee of the Walt Disney Company (where I worked for 7 years), I’m often asked “What’s your favorite Disney movie?” And it seems that everyone has an answer to this one, too…

My answer is easily The Hunchback of Notre Dame. Granted, this film hit the theaters the same week as my high school graduation, and I was hardly a ‘kid’ when I saw it. Perhaps it’s this reason why I enjoy the film. To me, this animated classic had some really deep themes that spoke to me.

Many of you, I’m sure, remember the summer between the end of High School and the start of College. I was a young idealist who believed in ‘equality for all.’ And Disney’s The Hunchback of Notre Dame shared this ideal. Like much of Victor Hugo’s fiction, the story is about the hypocrisy and dichotomy of the authoritative Church versus the will of the people.

This film dives into the theme with contradicting songs… the Church appointed Law Enforcement authority of Frollo tells his ward, Quasimodo, that the world is cruel and its safest if he stays “In Here” (referring to the bell tower of the Parisian Cathedral). Upon his departure, the song sung by Quasimodo is “Out There.” One lyric in particular has always had a profound impact on me. As Quasimodo is a prisoner of the bell tower, he sings of the townspeople below:

“Everyday they shout and scold and go about their lives,
Heedless of the gift it is to be them!”

Later in the film, as both Frollo and Quasimodo find themselves enchanted by the gypsy Esmerelda, Quasimodo refers to his infatuation as “Heaven’s Light.” Frollo calls it “Hell’s Fire,” in a song that remains one of the most creepy and villainous songs of all Disney animation.

Aside from the deep messages, this film has some great humor to it! Seinfeld star Jason Alexander voices Hugo, one of the comical gargoyles. Kevin Kline, who seems to be in some of the funniest movies ever (A Fish Called Wanda), brings life to Phoebus, the gallant hero. And Paul Kandel, who has done little else, is brilliant as my favorite Disney character… Clopin, the gypsy leader and unofficial storyteller.

Disney’s animation was a great storytelling medium for these characters. And as always, the work is masterful. The bird’s eye views of Paris are breathtaking. The animation during the song “Out … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Josh’s Response to Ethan Kreitzer’s List of his 50 Favorite Films of the Last Decade!

December 24th, 2009

Yesterday I posted my buddy Ethan Kreitzer’s list of his 50 Favorite Films of the Last Decade.

Movies that Ethan & I totally agree on and that I was really glad to see on his list because they are (in some cases) sort of obscure and also (in all cases) super-awesome: Roger Dodger, Snatch, Capturing the Friedmans, High Fidelity, Man on Wire, The Squid and the Whale, The Matador, The Incredibles, State and Main, Vanilla Sky, Zodiac, The Royal Tenenbaums, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, and the relentlessly phenomenal Adaptation.

Movies that I can’t believe he rated as high as he did: O Brother Where Art Thou (one of my least favorite Coen Brothers films, despite its terrific soundtrack), The Aviator (a very solid movie but nowhere near that high on my list of favorite films), No Country For Old Men (as I have written about on this site before, the ending really hurts the film in my eyes), Ocean’s Eleven (I am NOT a fan), School of Rock (amusing, but not a film I am in any rush to see a second time), Amelie (ditto), American Psycho (a decent film with a great performance by Christian Bale, but definitely not a standout of the decade for me), and Match Point (being one of the better Woody Allen films of the last decade does not, in my mind, make it a good film.  Go watch Crimes and Misdemeanors instead).

Movies on Ethan’s list that I haven’t seen: 24 Hour Party People, Shut Up and Sing (this has been on my to-watch list ever since it came out — it is on my Netflix queue, and I hope to get to see it soon), Monster (no interest), Chicago (no interest), Shattered Glass (minimal interest).

I thought about beginning to write a list of other great films from the past decade that Ethan left off his list, but that seems like an insurmountably great task.  I’m currently working on all of my end-of-the-year Best of 2009 lists, and that’s difficult enough!

Instead, as a counterpoint to Ethan’s list, let me direct you to another terrific Best-of-the-Decade list: regular Aintitcoolnews contributor Mr. Beaks’ list of his 100 Favorite Films of the Last Decade.  Here’s a link to numbers 100-76, 75-51, 50-26, and 25-1.

It’s a phenomenally well-written and comprehensive look back at the last decade of amazing films.  He has some insane selections (Bring it On, Observe and Report, Miami Vice, Jackass: The Movie, A.I.: Artificial Intelligence) but here are just a few of the great movies that I was thrilled to see him mention: Gone Baby Gone, Ratatouille, The 40 Year-Old Virgin, [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Ethan Kreitzer Lists his 50 Favorite Films of the Last Decade!

December 23rd, 2009

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Ethan Kreitzer to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

Ethan Kreitzer took a broader view of my question, and submitted a list of his 5o favorite films of the last decade!

50. 24 Hour Party People
49. You Can Count on Me
48. Amelie
47. Roger Dodger
46. Snatch
45. School of Rock
44. Catch Me If You Can
43. Shut Up & Sing
42. Capturing the Friedmans
41. Shaun of the Dead
40. The Wrestler
39. The Dark Knight
38. High Fidelity
37. 21 Grams
36. Milk
35. Lost in Translation
34. Monster
33. Best in Show
32. Man on Wire
31. Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead
30. American Psycho
29. Wet Hot American Summer
28. Vicky Christina Barcelona
27. Gosford Park
26. Chicago
25. The Squid and the Whale
24. Casino Royale
23. Matchstick Men
22. The Matador
21. The Incredibles
20. Ocean’s Eleven
19. State and Main
18. Vanilla Sky
17. Shattered Glass
16. There Will Be Blood
15. Punch-Drunk Love
14. Sideways
13. Memento
12. Match Point
11. Closer
10. Zodiac
9. Million Dollar Baby
8. No Country For Old Men
7. The Royal Tennenbaums
6. Almost Famous
5. O Brother Where Art Thou
4. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
3. The Aviator
2. Munich
1. Adaptation

Ethan Kreitzer is a talented musician and songwriter.  Formerly of the band Lincoln Conspiracy, he is currently studying how to actually make money in the music business.  Ethan is the biggest fan of The Larry Sanders Show that I’ve ever met, which only solidifies my high estimation of his good taste.

The series so far:


Citizen Kane

Hoosiers, The Frisco Kid, & Casablanca

Wax Philosophique

The Hunt for Red October

Raiders of the Lost Ark & The Dark Knight

The Sandlot & A Few Good Men

Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

Girls Just Want to Have Fun & Little Miss Sunshine

The Sandlot[continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Jeremy Myerson Discusses The Sandlot!

December 18th, 2009

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Jeremy Myerson to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

I was recently asked by Josh to be a guest contributor to MotionPicturesComics to help him out as he is surely getting no sleep as a new parent of twin girls! The assignment was to review my favorite film. Being the iconoclast that I am, I refused the task and changed it. To help Josh celebrate the wonder of children, and because Josh and I are long time friends (and co-sufferers) as Mets fans, I instead offer my review of my favorite kids’ baseball film!

There are countless websites and lists dedicated to the ‘Greatest Baseball Films,’ almost all of which exclude my entry for the top of the list: The Sandlot. This wonderful film accomplishes the true essence of baseball… Americana. The bulk of the film takes place in the 1960’s following the life of a runt kid (appropriately nicknamed ‘Smalls’) who moves into a new neighborhood and learns the game of baseball.

While the supporting group of local kids is somewhat reminiscent of The Bad News Bears, you’ll find much more heart and humanity in this motley crew. From the romantically desperate Squints, to Timmy and Tommy Timmons who repeat everything, to the wonderfully bullish and comical Ham Porter (who, of course, is the team’s catcher… think a young ‘Crash Davis’) The passion comes from the fictional future MLB player, Benny “The Jet” Rodriguez.

Baseball becomes the backdrop for the adventures of this group of neighborhood kids, as they invade the local community pool, explore the state fair and even try ‘dip’ like their Major League idols… and learn their lesson in a terrible and comical way. The adventures continue as their ‘Babe Ruth’ ball gets lost in the grouchy neighbor’s yard and is guarded by Hercules, the largest scariest film dog since Cujo.

For me, one of the finest moments in film history occurs when the kids play their only night game of the year on July 4th. The game is lit by the glow of the fireworks… Benny hits a ball up into the night and all the kids stop tracking the ball as they get lost in the glory of the fireworks display (set to Ray Charles’ ‘America the Beautiful’). Benny just keeps on running the bases… true baseball passion.

While this baseball movie has no scandals, no shattered lights and no ghosts in the cornfield it does have appeal to baseball fans of all ages. And it sure doesn’t hurt when you throw in a cameo by James Earl … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Stephanie Edelglass Discusses Girls Just Want to Have Fun & Little Miss Sunshine

December 16th, 2009

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Stephanie Edelglass to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

What unit of measurement should I use in picking my favorite movie of all time?  Should I go by my grandfather’s comment after seeing There’s Something About Mary, “It must have been good because I don’t remember the last time I stayed up for an entire movie”?  For me, that would eliminate almost every movie I began watching after 9pm.  Or should I go by the mood I was in when I left a movie?  By that caliber I’d choose It Could Happen to You because I left the theater with a feeling that life is good and sometimes people actually can be good and fair.  I remember leaving with a smile on my face.  What could be more important than the entertainment factor important when rating a movie?

I’ve decided to choose two favorite movies, one from my childhood and one from adulthood.  Girls Just Want to Have Fun is my childhood pick.  I recently subjected Josh to this movie and he doesn’t quite agree that this is a timeless classic.  He may have even thought it was formulaic!! Nonetheless, it has sentimental value, as there was at least a two-year period when I chose it every time I went to the video store.  I can still picture which shelf I could find it on each time I went into the little independent video store in Needham, MA.

Girls Just Want to Have Fun stars Sarah Jessica Parker as “Janie” and Helen Hunt as “Lynne”.  If you look closely, you’ll notice Shannon Doherty as the little sister of the lead actor.  Helen Hunt is the “bad girl” who leads Janie to follow her dream of becoming a dancer on Dance TV.  Adventure ensues.  I always wanted to have the guts to be Helen Hunt in this movie.  She turns her school uniform into a cool outfit with just a little Velcro and exudes a confidence that, as a twelve year old, I only dreamed of having in my life!  The eye candy who plays Janie’s dance partner, Jeff, is your classic “bad boy” and although he doesn’t have the gymnastics and dance training that Janie has, he holds his own throughout the movie.  There is a classic scene where Janie and Jeff are practicing their dance moves in the park and you can tell that romance is in the air.  The music is fabulous and the wardrobe is classic ’80s.  I recommend this as a must-see for anyone who wants to watch a classic … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Ethan Linden Discusses Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Ethan Linden to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

This is the type of assignment I would normally reject. Not writing for Josh’s blog, which I am honored to do, despite his somewhat upsetting regard for the finale of Battlestar Galactica. As a matter of policy, I refuse to state my favorite movie. People in my life know I watch a lot of movies (or at least I did until I had, you know, children) and they consider me a bit of a movie buff, so often I am asked to give my top ten, or top five favorite movies. I always politely decline, because really, what the hell does that mean?

I can recite pretty much all of This is Spinal Tap (“like lukewarm water”) but, given the right company, it’s still hysterical. I laugh every time I see Airplane! (“what a pisser” is just funny) and no matter how often I see Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, I can’t help wishing I lived his life, even now. Are these my favorite movies? How about a movie like this summer’s sadly under-seen The Hurt Locker, which has stayed with me with incredible vividness? Or, in a similar vein, a film like The Deer Hunter which gets more painful, and more powerful, as I get older? And don’t even get me started on The Godfather and The Godfather Part II (or the The Godfather Part III for that matter, though the speech is decidedly different). The list goes on and on, and it shifts as I shift, which is, I suppose, part of the power of movies.

But I have come to see that my unwillingness to pick a favorite as a sort of moral cowardice; it is, at its base, a deep hesitation to be judged on the basis of my choice. If I am unwilling to declare myself for one movie over all others, than what am I? If I am not for my movie, who will be for me?

My favorite movie is Who Framed Roger Rabbit?. Partly, this is a choice defined by nostalgia. The movie came out in 1988; I was eleven years old, and it was right in my wheelhouse. It is the first movie I remember going to see multiple times in the movie theaters, using my own money, dragging friends and family members, or homeless people, anyone really, who would join me. I loved Roger Rabbit, I thought it was brilliant and funny and poignant (though I would not have used that word) and … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger David Edelglass Discusses The Sandlot and A Few Good Men

Below is the third in a three-part contribution from guest blogger David Edelglass to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time. Click here for Part I and here for Part II.

My Favorite Movie From My Childhood: The Sandlot

This is another one of those movies that you can catch on ABC Family or some similar channel just about every month, and that’s A-OK with me.

Whenever I watch this movie, I find myself saying the same thing: “They don’t make kids movies like they used to.” It’s true. Most children’s movies these days are silly, over the top escapades that seem to think kids can’t appreciate a well written story or fully developed characters. The computer animated films have faired slightly better, but only Pixar has really been able to make movies that are funny, heartwarming, and family friendly (in this case I don’t just mean a movie that you can take your kids to, but one that will appeal to all audiences — something that even adults will find enjoyable).

The Sandlot is the story of nine kids during the summer of 1962 in L.A. Scott Smalls, a small, somewhat dorky kid, has just moved to the neighborhood with his mom and stepfather (Karen Allen and Denis Leary). He befriends a group of local kids who play baseball every day, and with the help of their de-facto leader, Benny Rodriguez, he slowly becomes one of the gang (and learns to play baseball to boot). The film is essentially the story of their summer, filled with swimming, giant dogs, James Earl Jones, and lots and lots of baseball.

The nine kids who make up the core of the movie are fantastic. Not only are the actors great, but the characters are all well developed and diverse. Each one has their own personality, and while some get more screen time than others, they all seem like real people, not vague character sketches.

Next time this film is on ABC Family, check it out. You’ll enjoy yourself, no matter how old you are.

Honorable Mention: The Last Starfighter

My Favorite Comedy:

This ones is tough. I spent a lot of time thinking about it in preparation for this post, and ultimately I decided that I just can’t decide. There are just too many great films out there, and comedies in particular seem to be very dependent on when you watch them and who you watch them with.

Some of those that have made me laugh the hardest upon first viewing are Planes Trains and Automobiles, The Hangover, Tropic Thunder, and Wedding Crashers, but movies … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger David Edelglass Discusses Raiders of the Lost Ark and The Dark Knight

Below is the second of a three-part contribution from guest blogger David Edelglass to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time. Click here for Part I.

My Favorite Action/Adventure Movie: Raiders of the Lost Ark

This is kind of a no brainer. Raise your hand if you never dressed up as Indiana Jones for Halloween or imagined yourself swinging across large crevices on your whip and outrunning giant boulders.

It is impossible to watch this film without getting caught up in the adventure and wishing you were there. This was a perfect meeting of the minds between three of Hollywood’s best and brightest at the time: George Lucas, Lawrence Kasdan, and Steven Spielberg. Lucas and Kasdan were just coming off of The Empire Strikes Back (which, along with Raiders, would be the high point in both their careers, in my opinion), and Spielberg was really hitting his stride, having already completed Jaws and Close Encounters of the Third Kind. (He would follow Raiders with ET). All three clearly were in love with the pulp adventures they had grown up enjoying, and it shows here. Indiana Jones is smart, cocky, handsome, but a bit rough around the edges, and Harrison Ford plays him to a T (though I am insanely curious to see what the movie would have been like if Tom Selleck had been free to take the role as originally intended). Karen Allen’s Marion Ravenwood is the perfect counterpart to Indy, and she is by far the best female lead of the entire series. John Rhys-Davies (Sallah) and Denholm Elliot (Marcus Brody) turn in fine supporting roles, as does Alfred Molina in a brief cameo in the opening scene (though I don’t know if you can really call it a cameo, as this was his first credited on-screen role).

Raiders is by far the strongest in the series, and hopefully if Spielberg and Lucas decide to dip back into the pool one more time, they’ll go back and watch this first movie to see what it was that made Raiders of the Lost Ark so special to begin with.

(Note that I did not refer to the movie as Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark. Lucas and Spielberg should be ashamed of themselves for that one)

Honorable Mention: The Goonies

The Movie That Absolutely Blew My Mind in the Theater: The Dark Knight

You all probably remember the hype the preceded this movie. The viral marketing campaign before its release was astounding.  Then, with the death of Heath Ledger, this film became a must see. We geeks were foaming … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger David Edelglass Discusses The Hunt For Red October

December 9th, 2009

Below is the first of a three-part contribution from guest blogger David Edelglass to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

What is my favorite movie of all time?  That is a question which many people have asked me over the years, and every time I give a different answer. Truthfully, I don’t really have one favorite movie. Partly this is because my tastes have changed over the years. The movies I liked when I was twelve aren’t necessarily the movies that I’m still interested in.

But honestly, I think the question of what is my one most favorite movie ever is impossible to answer. There are too many variables: How old I am or what mood I’m in at any given moment, plus the many different genres of movies. I mean how can I compare a movie that I saw on home video when I was twelve and happy to one I saw in the theaters when I was 18 and pissed off at the world (not that I necessarily was at that age, but you get where I’m going with this). On the one hand you’ve got the incredible storytelling, acting and general film construction on display in The Godfather, and on the other hand, there is the incredible hilariousness and craziness of Blazing Saddles. It’s like comparing apples to oranges, and I for one just can’t do it. So to best answer the question of my favorite movies of all time, I’ve decided on a few important categories and tried to pick my favorite movie for each. So here goes nothing.

My Favorite Serious Movie: The Hunt for Red October

Even though I just got finished saying how I couldn’t pick my one favorite movie, if someone put a gun to my head and forced me to do so, this would definitely be in consideration. Riveting story: check. Intense cat and mouse submarine chases that will keep you on the edge of your seat: check. Great character actors chewing the scenery together: check (pretty much every single actor in this movie is someone you would recognize even if you don’t know their name, including James Earl Jones and former senator Fred Thompson). This movie has it all.

Set during the end of the cold war, Alec Baldwin plays Jack Ryan, a CIA analyst who gets in a bit over his head when he discovers that the USSR had just launched a new attack submarine capable of running almost completely silent. And who better to play the captain of said sub, the Red October, then Sean Connery, complete with awesome … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Brian Raphael Waxes Philosophical About His Favorite Movie!

December 7th, 2009

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Brian Raphael to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

Wax Philosophique

Ah, the simple joy of knowing the answers to life’s daily questions, of listening to friends’ queries, always smug in the ability to answer anything and everything that any mere layman should happen to wonder about. A knowing smirk, a small shrug that assures the audience that such a question is quite irrelevant anyway – such is the life of Le Philosopher!

But of course! Our all-knowing Philosopher surely snickered at a request from his brother-in-law to answer the question “What is your favorite movie ever?” “Bah!” he probably thought, as the multitude of impossibilities, false assumptions and categorical mistakes the question posed swam through his head, “such a question eez impossible to answer!”

Perhaps it was due to the Philosopher’s overly generous nature, or warm feelings for his sister’s husband, that he chose to put pen to paper and attempt an answer. Ruminations on the meaning of life, the meaning of death and everything in between can be tough, so deciding upon his favorite movie ever should be quite simple he thought as he plotted the various methods of dazzling his sure-to-be-rapt readers.

Candle burning, ink well filled, and duty-worn fountain pen at the ready – it was not long before our hero realized that this might prove tougher than he had thought.

To the outside world – a humble accountant, toiling away in a Manhattan high-rise; ah, but from the inside! His brain was alight with neurons firing across synapses, wrinkles forming and growing through time as one thought led to another which led to yet another as he toyed with different perspectives, discarding each just as quickly for a multitude of reasons – attempting to find a path that led to fruitful ground.

Could it be that the answer to this riddle lay somewhere in the question itself? Terms slowly but surely met their respective definitions. Some were simple terms – movie: a motion picture that had been in general release, your: his, ever: in his lifetime – but ‘favorite’ caused a near short circuit in our humble philosopher’s brain.

“Favorite?!” he said to himself incredulously. “But zis term means nothing!”

As the night grew long and his candle burned low, he remained at his post, determined to fulfill his intellectual quest.

“Perhaps ‘favorite’ implies the movie that I have viewed the most times during my life” he wondered aloud as he fondly recalled beautiful afternoons living in the country as a child…when he and his good … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Ed Gelb Discusses Hoosiers, The Frisco Kid, and Casablanca!

December 4th, 2009

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Ed Gelb to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time. It is very hard to pick just one favorite movie of all time. There are so many movies that represent so many different genres. For me, the film’s topic having meaning to me, its entertainment, and its connection to my family all play prominent roles in my decision. Using those criteria, I came up with three finalists. They are: Casablanca, The Frisco Kid, and Hoosiers. Pretty eclectic, right? Below, I will explain why and reveal my final choice.

Casablanca is a romance situated in Vichy France during WWII. An all-star cast that purportedly thought they were filming a dud, it turned out to be an enormous hit. I first saw this movie with my parents and some of my six siblings on TV. There is no doubt that sharing that movie with my family enhanced it for me. Ingrid Bergman’s beauty is striking and definitely had an impact on the teenage-me. The ending had a nice twist and a great ending line. One of the things about Casablanca that I love is that any time I’m flipping through the channels and come across it I can watch it. It always entertains.

The Frisco Kid combines two Gelb family themes: Judaism and living out west. I am a rabbi and I grew up in Laramie, WY. This is a family favorite that is quoted by all of us regularly. Gene Wilder and Harrison Ford were perfectly cast. The scenes with the Amish and at a monastery are hilarious. The only down-side to the movie is the slower start. My brother, Jim, met Harrison Ford at an event a few years ago and told him that The Frisco Kid was our family’s favorite movie of his. Ford looked up and said, “really?” This is another movie I can watch virtually at any time. It always leaves me with a smile.

One day, I get a package in the mail from my parents. It is a “Monon Line” coffee mug. I’m perplexed. I call my parents to thank them. They say, “do you get it?” I say, “no, what?” “Monon Line, Hoosiers.” Still perplexed, my parents quote a rather obscure line from the movie from the disgruntled assistant coach that gets fired to Coach Dale. He says, “if you mess up this team I’ll strap your hide to a rail and send you up the Monon Line.” That netted me a mug. Hoosiers is one of two movies that all eight original Gelbs saw together in a … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

Guest Blogger Ethan Katz Discusses Citizen Kane!

Below is a contribution from guest blogger Ethan Katz to our continuing series in which I asked several of my close friends and colleagues to name their Favorite Movie of All Time.

When I first saw Citizen Kane, I was only seven or eight years old, and I knew little more about the film than the fact that critics had repeatedly dubbed it “the greatest movie ever made,” and that it took its inspiration from the real life story of famed newspaper publisher and political figure William Randolph Hearst. For these reasons, I looked forward to the showing, but I soon found that much of the film’s brilliance and most of its references were lost on me. Yet twenty-some years and several more critical showings later, I have become deeply attached to the film and find that it continues to offer new insights, visually, cinematographically, historically, and even philosophically.

At the most basic level, Citizen Kane is a deeply American story, and in a sense a deeply tragic one. The parents, particularly the mother, of Charles Foster Kane, a talented and precocious young boy, decide that their inheritance of a gold mine offering tremendous wealth should cause them to send the boy to be raised by a Mr. Walter Thatcher, whose top hat and posh British accent immediately tell us that he is the very embodiment of East Coast elitism. After becoming master of his own wealth at age 25, Kane decides to enter the newspaper business. He soon builds the greatest newspaper empire on earth. During that time, however, he also evolves from a muckraking idealist into a publicity hound with boundless ambition. A love affair with Susan Alexander, a hapless “singer” (the mocking quotation marks are the film’s) destroys Kane’s first marriage and his political ambitions. Alexander, who becomes his second wife, leaves him when she grows weary of his self-centeredness and the utter isolation of their enormous and lavish castle, “Xanedu.” There, Kane dies, an isolated, sad man, imprisoned by his own wealth and his personal failings.

Part of what makes Citizen Kane such a powerful film is that it chooses to portray a famous man’s life not through a conventional narrative of his greatest deeds but through the eyes of those who knew him up close: his business associates, longtime friends, ex-lover, and others. Moreover, though made in 1941, it does so in what we now call “fractured time,” moving repeatedly between various phases of Kane’s life and personal relationships. Orson Welles, creator and star of the film, seems highly self-conscious of the cinematic and story-telling revolution that such methodology portends. In fact, at its outset, the film shows a quick, incomplete newsreel on … [continued]

Browse Josh's Portfolio and the Comic, Reviews or Blog archive.

What is Your Favorite Movie of All Time?

November 30th, 2009

To help me keep regular updates going while Steph and I adjust to the two newest (and loveliest!) additions to our family, I have solicited a number of guest bloggers for the site for the next few weeks.  (I figured my just posting new baby pictures every day probably wasn’t the type of “regular content” that most of you are looking for!)

I posed a simple question to a number of my close friends and colleagues: What is your favorite movie of all time?

I received several wonderful pieces in response that discuss a wide variety of films (so far, no duplication!).  Each writer approached the question from a different angle.  While most discuss the strengths of the film they listed as their favorite — what made it a success and what gives it its enduring power — many also branched out to talk about the first time they saw the film, what personal meaning it holds from them, or other tangents.

Starting on Wednesday, I’ll be posting these pieces in a continuing series over the next several weeks (interspersed with other posts by yours truly on a variety of different topics, of course!).  I think this is a really exciting series that provides a look at an array of different amazing films (some very famous, some a little less so).  I hope you agree!… [continued]